Evaluation of Academic Dissertations via Mindfulness in Children Using Content Analysis Method
PDF
Cite
Share
Request
Review
P: 482-490
October 2024

Evaluation of Academic Dissertations via Mindfulness in Children Using Content Analysis Method

Bezmialem Science 2024;12(4):482-490
1. Bezmialem Vakıf University Faculty of Health Sciences, Department of Occupational Therapy, İstanbul, Türkiye
2. Bezmialem Vakıf University Faculty of Health Sciences, Department of Physiotherapy and Rehabilitation, İstanbul, Türkiye
No information available.
No information available
Received Date: 01.11.2023
Accepted Date: 14.05.2024
Online Date: 04.11.2024
Publish Date: 04.11.2024
PDF
Cite
Share
Request

ABSTRACT

Mindfulness, which means being aware of the moment and what is happening around and accepting it unconditionally, is especially valuable for children who are in the age of discovery and development. Research question: In the recent years Council of Higher Education (CoHE) Thesis Center publications, how has the mindfulness been studied in Turkish children? Searches were conducted of CoHE Thesis Center until October 2023 to identify dissertations (master of science, doctorate, specialization in medicine). Using the keywords “mindfulness” and “child”, “mindfulness” and “children” were scanned. Studies which did not have full text access and did not include assessment and intervention on mindfulness with children were excluded. Eighty-nine dissertations met the study’s inclusion criteria. Once duplicates were removed and were screened for eligibility, totally 27 studies between 2018 and September 2023 were reviewed. Types of these studies were as follows: 22 were master of science, 3 were doctorate and 2 were specialization in medicine. The most common field outcomes were psychology and education and training. Within the scope of this determination, there were two main themes: evaluation methods (n=20) and intervention methods (n=7). While there were 10 studies between 2017 and 2019, 17 studies were found in the last four years. It has been observed that postgraduate dissertations on mindfulness have increased in recent years. Although the researchers on the subject appear to be from different scientific fields and disciplines and that interest in the subject has increased, future studies are needed to create a general consensus.

Keywords:
Academic dissertations, theses, mindfulness, child

Introduction

Aware is associated with aspects of individuals such as being open, non-judgmental, friendly, curious, accepting, compassionate and kind. Mindfulness is explained as moment-by-moment awareness of thoughts, emotions, bodily sensations and the environment (1). Mindfulness has recently begun to draw interest in scientific and popular discourses in daily life (2). It is also studied in various disciplines, especially psychology, physiology, health services, neuroscience and art. In this context, mindfulness research shows that mindfulness-based approaches are aimed at improving stress management, cognitive, emotional and interpersonal functions (3).

Mindfulness studies include various age and focus groups. Studies on its effects on children that one of the focus groups within this scope have started to improve. “Child” which includes the 0-18 age group, is the period before adulthood (4). For this reason, mindfulness studies implemented on individuals who have not yet stepped into adulthood provide that individuals in this age group are supported in terms of academic, social and cognitive functions. Additionally, mindfulness practices are emphasized in this critical period to support the development of different skills (5).

Considering that about half of mental disorders occur before the age of 14, it is clear that the period between the ages of 0-18 is especially transit for adulthood (6). It is important to screen child development, evaluations at an early stage, determine possible situations and apply appropriate protocols regularly. Besides all this, it has been shown that practices aimed at evaluating and improving individuals’ mindfulness are also successful in the treatment of medical conditions such as depression, anxiety, chronic pain, heart diseases and cancer (7). For this reason, mindfulness-based interventions are accepted as a hopeful approach and are followed with increasing interest in the field of mental health. Mindfulness practices include movement-based practices such as mindfulness meditations, breathing exercises, yoga, and approaches that protect attention and enhance focus by choosing a focus point (7, 8). Mindfulness-based intervention results in enhanced mindfulness through the mindfulness regulation process and a more integrated sense of personal accomplishment among key and common goals (7). Mindfulness-based rehabilitation approaches can be an effective keynote for developing self-regulation by facilitating the individual to learn how to be calmer or more relaxed in general and how to calm himself/herself in times of anxiety or potential threat (9).

As long as mindfulness-based assessment, practices and methods become gradually widespread, the concept of mindfulness is becoming a term that is increasingly heard and included in daily life, along with many academic researches, books, projects and trainings, especially in health services (7, 10). However, the scientific basis on which this issue is researched has not been clearly revealed to what extent it is addressed both academically and practically. For this reason, postgraduate theses that include the child population on mindfulness are an important data source. In this study, the postgraduate theses were examined according to their years, type, institute, subjects, theses types, methods and findings for children in Türkiye until October 2023. This research aimed to determine what the current situation was so far in theses whereby the focus group was children and to reveal the needs for future studies.

Methods

This research was fulfil through the document analysis, which is one of the qualitative research techniques of postgraduate theses conducted for children in Türkiye. Qualitative research is a type of research in which methods such as observation, interview and documentation are used to collect data. In other words, it is an approach that is based on theory creation and prioritizes research and understanding of social phenomena within the framework to which they depend (11). In this research, postgraduate theses were collected by document analysis. Document analysis consists of a series of processes that occur within the examining and evaluating printed and/or electronic (computer-based and internet-accessible) materials (12). The data obtained were examined by the content analysis method, and similar data were brought together within the framework of categories and interpreted through content analysis (11).

In recent years, it has been observed that the number of mindfulness-based studies has increased with intense interest. For this reason, postgraduate theses published on mindfulness in children in Türkiye were accessed. In accessing theses documents; the keywords “mindfulness”, “child” and “children” were used in selecting theses on the subject from the Council of Higher Education (CoHE)-Thesis Center (2023) website (https://tez.yok.gov.tr/UlusalTezMerkezi/). Master of science, doctorate and specialization of medicine postgraduate theses accessed with these keywords were transferred to the computer in pdf format. Published theses fulfilling the following criteria were included: (a) open to full text access, (b) in Turkish or English language, and (c) focus group should be children. Theses on different focus groups were excluded. Twenty-seven postgraduate theses that met the inclusion criteria were reached. The flow chart of the study is given in Figure 1. The aforementioned theses were subsequently collated within the context of main categories through the application of content analysis, and the primary findings were subsequently summarised and interpreted.

Results

Firstly only the word “mindfulness” was scanned in the CoHE National Thesis Center and 494 postgraduate theses were found between May 2011 and October 2023. Then, when the words “mindfulness” and “child” were searched, 60 theses were found between August 2013 and October 2023; when the words “mindfulness” and “children” were searched 29 postgraduate theses were found between June 2018 and October 2023. Duplicate studies (n=20) were excluded, the titles and abstracts of the remaining 69 studies were examined. Forty-two of these studies were excluded because the focus group was not children, and as a result, 27 studies were examined (13-39). Those studies were published between 2017 and October 2023. Looking at the distribution by years, there was 1 study in 2017, 3 studies in 2018, 6 studies in 2019, 5 studies in 2020, 4 studies in 2021, 3 studies in 2022 and 5 studies in 2023. Twenty-four of the studies were authored in Turkish, while three were written in English.

The most postgraduate theses on mindfulness in children were master of science theses (n=22) with 81.48%, doctorate theses with 11.11% (n=3) and specialization in medicine theses with 7.4% (n=2), respectively. Distribution of these theses according to the institutes and departments they were affiliated with were as follows: education [(n=16); institute of education (n=6), institute of educational sciences (n=9), institute of educational technology (n=1)], social [(n=8); institute of social sciences (n=7), institute of economics and social sciences (n=1)], health [(n=1); institute of health sciences (n=1)], psychiatry [(n=2); department of child and adolescent mental health and diseases].

Of the studies 74.07% that met the inclusion criteria consisted of evaluation studies (n=20). The names of the studies, theses type, methods, main findings and results of these studies are given in Table 1. It was observed that 22 had a quantitative, 1 had a qualitative, and 4 had a mixed (quantitative and qualitative) study design.

Of the studies 25.92% that met the inclusion criteria consisted of intervention (n=7) studies. The names of the studies, theses types, methods, interventions, main findings and results of these studies are given in Table 2.

Discussion

In this study, postgraduate theses were researched through mindfulness in children in Türkiye and it was revealed that it was a multidisciplinary field that attracted attention in recent years. Researchers who study mindfulness emphasize that although the field has gained popularity recently, it is still a developing field (40). It is thought cherish the hope to plan mindfulness-based studies with qualitative, quantitative and mixed methods, as well as to disseminate studies with a high level of evidence and examining with follow-up.

Every human is considered a child until the age of 18, and with the special status provided, the rights of children to life and development are protected (4). For this reason, studies involving children cover the ages of 0-18. In the studies examined, it was seen that the sample groups were determined according to age. However, there is no mention of a standardized categorization. Given as examples: the study by Kıdil (13) titled “Investigation of the Awareness of 5-6 Years Old Children and Their Families on Correct Nutritional Behaviors” and conducted with 5-6 age group; the study by Dursun (14) titled “Investigation of the Effect of Parent Attitudes on the Self-Comfort Levels and Conscious Awareness Based Self-Efficiency of Special Talent Children Aged 9-13” and conducted with 9-13 age group, and the study by Alpay (36) titled “The Effect of Mindfulness Based Physical Education Lessons on the Mindfulness, Emotional and Psychological Well-Being Levels of Primary School 3rd and 4th Grade Students” and conducted with 3-4 grade students (Tables 1, 2). Studies in the literature on mindfulness include different age groups and life span (41). Mindfulness needs to be evaluated and examined for specific age groups in intervention programs.

Although the concept of mindfulness has its origins in the teachings of Buddha (42), the first scientific publication was found in 1857. The subject of mindfulness in children has been in the literature since 1872. Despite the fact that there has been an increasing interest in the studies examined in our study for years, the most studies were found in 2019. However, the difference in the number of studies compared to other years is negligible. When looking at the literature, it can be seen that the interest in studies on the subject continues to increase. The creation of environments where researchers can present and share their information on the subject will be a source of motivation.

For all that mindfulness is a field that develops with its roots in psychology, it is seen to be involved in many different scientific fields such as neuroscience, medicine, psychiatry (43). Additionally, mindfulness has been studied on various topics such as addiction, chronic pain, immunity, health behaviors, depression relapse, depression and anxiety symptoms, attention control and focus (41). From this perspective, mindfulness has a rich scope. Similarly, many different areas were included in the studies examined. However, it has been observed that it is not discussed as in the studies examined in scientific fields such as occupational therapy, cardiac rehabilitation, vocational rehabilitation and cognitive rehabilitation, which have an important place in the literature (41, 44-46). In this respect, it seems that there is a need for postgraduate theses on the subject of mindfulness in these scientific fields in Türkiye. In addition, studies in the national literature such as “Effect of Mindfulness Based Cognitive Therapy Program on Psychological Symptom Levels of Schizophrenia Patients” (47) and “Mindfulness-Based Cognitive Therapy: A Review” (48) were achieved.

Qualitative research is a subjective, holistic and process-oriented type of study that investigates the nature of real-life phenomena (11). However, in quantitative studies, this is the opposite. Quantitative research comprehends objective, targeted and result-oriented research types that objectify situations, facts and events and reveal them in a way that can be observed, measured and expressed numerically (49). The majority of the studies examined were created with a quantitative design. When the studies on mindfulness in the literature are examined, it is stated that very few studies have qualitative design, but the results are similar to quantitative studies (9). Therefore, findings of this study are similar to the literature. Some of the studies examined included information about their design in the method section, some studies did not. This situation caused the researchers to have difficulty in determining the methods. Besides, study designs need to be clearly stated. The lack of sharp separation of qualitative and quantitative research methods leads to confusion in the evaluation of research results. All qualitative studies emphasize the issues and events that develop in the natural environment, and when examining these facts, the questions of how and why are answered instead of how many or how much. In consequence, instead of collecting numerical data, administering interventions or treatments as in quantitative research, qualitative research helps further explore and understand quantitative data as well as generate hypotheses. A study can be conducted entirely with qualitative or quantitative methods, as well as a mixed-method research combining qualitative and quantitative approaches can also be planned (49).

Study Limitations

This study, which is based on the examination of postgraduate studies on mindfulness for children, draws attention that most of the postgraduate theses are evaluation-oriented. Due to increasing evidence of the positive impact of mindfulness on psychological health, emotional well-being, learning and physical health, assessing mindfulness has become important (31). However, the limitations of this study are that assessment and intervention methods related to mindfulness are not compared with each other, only postgraduate theses are examined, and mindfulness studies related to only children are included.

Conclusion

Researches are needed with professional groups such as occupational therapy, physiotherapy rehabilitation, psychology, and neuroscience in order to develop a further comprehensive understanding of the studies on mindfulness more collaborative/multidisciplinary. Although it seems likely that interest in mindfulness will continue, considering the progress made so far, it is recommended that the impact and development of mindfulness-based studies on human life be examined in populations with different characteristics and with various methods.

Footnotes

References

1
Baer R, Crane C, Miller E, Kuyken W. Doing no harm in mindfulness-based programs: Conceptual issues and empirical findings. Clin Psychol Rev. 2019;71:101-14.
2
King E, Badham R. The wheel of mindfulness: a generative framework for second-generation mindful leadership. Mindfulness. 2020;11:166-76.
3
Sedlmeier P, Eberth J, Schwarz M, Zimmermann D, Haarig F, Jaeger S, et al. The psychological effects of meditation: a meta-analysis. Psychol Bull. 2012;138:1139-71.
4
United Nations. General Assembly. Convention on the Rights of the Child, 20 November 1989. Annu Rev Popul Law. 1989;16:485-501.
5
Tan LB. A critical review of adolescent mindfulness-based programmes. Clin Child Psychol Psychiatry. 2016;21:193-207.
6
Kessler RC, Berglund P, Demler O, Jin R, Merikangas KR, Walters EE. Lifetime prevalence and age-of-onset distributions of DSM-IV disorders in the National Comorbidity Survey Replication. Arch Gen Psychiatry. 2005;62:593-602.
7
Baer RA. Mindfulness-based treatment approaches: clinician’s guide to evidence base and applications. 2nd ed. Oxford: Elsevier; 2014.
8
Bishop SR, Lau M, Shapiro S, Carlson L, Anderson ND, Carmody J, et al. Mindfulness: a proposed operational definition. Clin Psychol Sci Pract. 2004;11:230-41.
9
Barrett CJ. Mindfulness and rehabilitation: teaching yoga and meditation to young men in an alternative to incarceration program. Int J Offender Ther Comp Criminol. 2017;61:1719-38.
10
Kabat-Zinn J. Mindfulness-based interventions in context: past, present, and future. Clin Psychol Sci Prac. 2003;10:144-56.
11
Berg BL, Lune H. Qualitative research methods for social sciences. 9th ed. Essex: Pearson; 2017.
12
Bowen GA. Document analysis as a qualitative research method. Qual Res J. 2009;9:27-40.
13
Kıdil Z. Investigation of the awareness of 5-6 years old children and their families on correct nutritional behaviors (dissertation). İstanbul: Fatih Sultan Mehmet Vakıf Univ. 2021.
14
Dursun E. Investigation of the effect of parent attitudes on the self-comfort levels and conscious awareness based self-efficiency of special talent children aged 9-13 (dissertation). İstanbul: İstanbul Aydın Univ. 2023.
15
Önal Y. The Examination of exam anxiety with individual and stability therapy (ACT) model in individuals from 12-15 years (dissertation). İstanbul: Üsküdar Univ. 2020.
16
Karzı V. The relationship among mindfulness, digital game addiction and demographic variables (dissertation). İstanbul: Bahçeşehir Univ. 2020.
17
Devrim Kahraman B. Investigation of the relationship mindfulness-based self-efficacy, self-compassion and happiness levels in children. İstanbul: İstanbul Univ. 2020.
18
Tohumcu HZ. Well-being children: parental attitudes and the role of mindfulness (dissertation). Gaziantep: Hasan Kalyoncu Univ. 2022.
19
Koçyiğit ÖÖ. Social mindfulness in intergroup context: the role of socio-cognitive skills (dissertation). İstanbul: İstanbul 29 Mayıs Univ. 2023.
20
Kaya A. Emotional abuse awareness of parents of 4th grade primary school students (dissertation). Kocaeli: Kocaeli Univ. 2020.
21
Küçükgüzel Z. Investigation of the relationship between perfectionism, self-compassion, mindfulness, self-esteem, and perceived severity of stuttering in children who stutter (dissertation). İstanbul: Üsküdar Univ. 2021.
22
Yazgılı Kahveci NG. Evaluation of identity development and mindfulness in adolescents with and without nonsuicidal self-injurious behavior (dissertation). Ankara: Hacettepe Univ. 2020.
23
Aydın İ. Evaluation of emotion regulation and mindfullness in adolescents with and without identity confusion (dissertation). Ankara: Hacettepe Univ. 2017.
24
Yılmaz Z. Investigation of the relationship between covid- 19 phobia, metacognitive problems and mindfulness level in high school students (dissertation). İstanbul: İstanbul Aydın Univ. 2022.
25
Altan B. Investigation the mediator role of mindfulness and metacognition in the relationship between nomophobia and alexithymia (dissertation). İstanbul: İstanbul Aydın Univ. 2019.
26
Taşkın Z. Development of awareness in self-administrative skills in preschool children: Ataşehir case (dissertation). İstanbul: Uskudar Univ. 2019.
27
Karadoğan E. Investigation of the development of mindfulness in middle childhood in the context of mindful parenting and the child’s socio-emotional and socio-cognitive skills (dissertation). İstanbul: İstanbul 29 Mayıs Univ. 2022.
28
Keskin B. Investigation of the relationship between digital game addiction, resilience and mindfulness levels of secondary school students (dissertation). Bursa: Bursa Uludağ Univ. 2019.
29
Ayhan AS. The mediator effect of mindfulness in the relationship between perceived stress level and quality of life in pediatric asthma (dissertation). İstanbul: Işık Univ. 2020.
30
Gözütok EN. Mediating effects of emotion regulation and creative problem solving in the relationship between mindfulness and foreign language learning anxiety (dissertation). Bolu: Bolu Abant İzzet Baysal Univ. 2023.
31
Taşkın SZ. Assessing mindfulness in school-aged children: development and validation of bau mindfulness scale (BAU-MSC) (dissertation). İstanbul: Bahçeşehir Univ. 2018.
32
Barış Ş. Mindfulness levels of gifted and non-gifted 3 and 4th grades students (dissertation). İstanbul: Bahçeşehir Univ. 2018.
33
Önoğlu Yıldırım E. The effects of mindfulness based yoga intervention on preschoolers’ self-regulation ability (dissertation). Ankara: İhsan Doğramacı Bilkent Univ. 2019.
34
Aydın A. Investigation of the effect of mindfulness education program on the emotional intelligence, self-perception and executive functioning level of pre-school children (dissertation). Ankara: Gazi Univ. 2023.
35
Özen Koç Ö. Effectiveness of mindfulness based program on pre-adolescents (dissertation). Ankara: Hacettepe Univ. 2023.
36
Alpay MR. The effect of mindfulness based physical education lessons on the mindfulness, emotional and psychological well-being levels of primary school 3rd and 4th grade students (dissertation). Ankara: Ankara Univ. 2021.
37
Yazğan Ö. Mindful school program for elementary school children and the effects of the program on children (dissertation). İstanbul: Bahçeşehir Univ. 2019.
38
Yıldızhan Ö. Effect of mindfulness based anger management program on mindfulness and anger management skills on children (dissertation). İstanbul: Bahçeşehir Univ. 2019.
39
Çollak N. The 8 week mindfulness program for preschool children and the effects of the program on children (dissertation). İstanbul: Bahçeşehir Univ. 2018.
40
Williams JM, Kabat-Zinn J. Mindfulness: diverse perspectives on its meaning, origins and applications. New York: Routledge; 2013.
41
Creswell JD. Mindfulness interventions. Annu Rev Psychol. 2017;68:491-516.
42
Levey J, Levey M. Roots and shoots of mindfulness. Subtle Energies Magazine [Internet]. 2018 [cited 2023 Oct 30];28:23-39. Available from:https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=&ved =2ahUKEwiI4PzCrp6CAxVdSvEDHYKqDBwQFnoECBMQA Q&url=https %3A%2F%Fosf.io%2Fm38rg%2Fdownload&usg=AOvVaw2jY91cl-nIFmx1A5MHk8OH&opi=89978449
43
Keeler JL, Kan C, Treasure J, Himmerich H. Novel treatments for anorexia nervosa: Insights from neuroplasticity research. Eur Eat Disord Rev. 2023.
44
Hardison ME, Roll SC. Mindfulness interventions in physical rehabilitation: a scoping review. Am J Occup Ther. 2016;70:7003290030p1-p9.
45
Davis LW, Lysaker PH, Kristeller JL, Salyers MP, Kovach AC, Woller S. Effect of mindfulness on vocational rehabilitation outcomes in stable phase schizophrenia. Psychol Serv. 2015;12:303-12.
46
Nauta IM, Bertens D, Fasotti L, Fieldhouse J, Uitdehaag BMJ, Kessels RPC, et al. Cognitive rehabilitation and mindfulness reduce cognitive complaints in multiple sclerosis (REMIND-MS): a randomized controlled trial. Mult Scler Relat Disord. 2023;71:104529.
47
Demir V, Hızlı G. Bilinçli farkındalık temelli bilişsel terapi programının şizofreni hastalarının ruhsal belirti düzeylerine etkisi. Current Research and Reviews in Psychology and Psychiatry. 2023;3:46-63.
48
İnce DK, Demir S. Mindfulness-based cognitive therapy: a review. GUHES. 2023;5:77-82.
49
Goertzen MJ. Introduction to quantitative research and data. Libr Technol Rep. 2017;53:12-8.